3.09.2011

Different Readings of Gorgias on (not) Being

Previously, I posted a rough sketch of my argument about Jim Gee's definition of literacy as "ways of being in the world." Below are a few more paragraphs that spell out the argument in more detail.

In short what I want to ask is “What does it mean to Be literate?” a question which entails a shift from epistemic questions to ontological ones. We might productively shift our attention to how we understand Gee’s statement about literacy as a way of Being in the world and inquire into how literacy shapes, influences, and perhaps even constitutes some part of our Being. This has been rather prohibited from the standpoint of social construction and cultural studies, which understand the world and Being (physis) as separate from any discursive representation or identity. Strong versions of social construction reduce everything to nomos, to matters of convention or law, denying that we can ever have access to physis itself. However, recent scholars in philosophy and rhetoric have begun theorizing Being and ontology in ways that admit the arbitrariness of the sign, to its function within social systems such as language and literacy. These discussions are not completely compatible nor are they yet fully worked out. One debate, between object-oriented ontologists (OOO) and process-relational theorists (PRT), occurs via weblogs of scholars advocating for their understanding of being. Because these are ongoing scholarly approaches to Being, I am not going to advocate for any one “correct” version of understanding Being or Being literate. However, I do want to outline some of these discussions and relate them to Gee’s description.

Such a project can explore an area described by Victor Vitanza (1991) as a Third Sophistic. For Vitanza, this is not a chronological movement stemming from an originary “first sophistic” of ancient Athenian rhetors and following the subsequent Roman “second sophistic” of the second century CE. Rather, a third sophistic, as Vitanza describes it “is not necessarily sequential” (emphasis in original), but inclusive of Gorgias, Nietzsche, Lyotard, de Man, Foucault and Lacan (117). A third sophistic counts to “many things” rather than simply one or two, a move that breaks up monist and binarist patterns of thinking. Such thinkers “theorize about the impossibility/Resistance of the Logos (reason, logic, law, argumentation, history) to Theory/Totalization, because of the Gorgian Kairos and the Lacanian Real — both of which enter the Logos and break up the cycle of the antitheses,” thereby breaking with the given patterns of difference and creating something new (117). Elsewhere, Vitanza argues that the history of rhetoric has been founded on negation or lack and a Third Sophistic can re-think the writing of rhetoric’s history with careful concern for the “negative essentializing” done within monistic or binaristic ways of thinking (1997, 12). While Vitanza critiques how logos has been used for such negative essentializing, he takes this one step further by pointing out this has often been done “to varying degrees in respect to physis and nomos” (12). Vitanza, then, offers clues as to how we might look at and understand Gee’s definition of literacy as something that encompasses more than just representation.

Gorgias and Classical Rhetoric on Being

Scott Cosigny argues a point similar to Vitanza, noting how “several scholars argue that Gorgias’ remarks on language, knowledge, and truth anticipate the views of such twentieth century thinkers as Heidegger, Derrida, Wittgenstein, Ayer, Rorty, and Fish” (1-2). For Cosigny, Gorgias presents us with an antifoundational account, one which coherently posits reality as the effect of various language games. Cosigny argues that as a result, “the most fundamental element of discourse is the maneuver, or trope; and discourse as a whole is composed of various maneuvers that may be used in various games” (77, emphasis in original). This is in sharp contrast to Aristotle who “sees tropes such as metaphors and puns as ‘deviations’ from the proper function of language, that of naming essential features of the world itself” (77).

We can see similarity here not only to Vitanza, but to Gee’s descriptions of Discourse and semiotic domains. For Gee, Discourse and semiotic domains are always a social network of practices and ways of making meaning from within a specific situation rather than from an abstract, decontextualized one. Gee describes semiotic domain as “any set of practices that recruits one or more modalities (e.g., oral or written language, images, equations, symbols. Sounds, gestures, graphs, artifacts, etc.) to communicate distinctive types of meanings” (18). Like Gorgias, Gee downplays the specific content of the communication in favor of the maneuver involved, a maneuver that is not completely arbitrary but potentially given within the semiotic domain.

Just how these maneuvers work, though, is something not always clear given either Cosigny’s or Gee’s arguments. While Cosigny admits his reading “underwrites Vitanza’s assertion that Gorgias is the principal precourser to our own Third Sophistic” (210), his articulation and defense of how Gorgias viewed nomos appears at odds with Vitanza’s critique of negative essentializing. Much of this critique proceeds from disenabling qualities of negation, diaeresis, negative dialectic and the like. But rather than fight against or negate that which does the negating, Vitanza embarks upon a theory of “denegation,” or affirming the negative. For Vitanza, “It is not just a matter of doing away with physis, some universal notion of it, and accepting nomos, our differences, but of perpetually denegating both physisneg. and nomos” (15). Thus, even those things which will necessarily be excluded from logos and by virtue of the imperfections of language, are still present and affirming that present absence is not only a strategy common to members of a third sophistic, but required to address the problems inherent to the hierarchies and domination of monistic and binaristic thinking.

Cosigny, however, while admitting Gorgias does not hold the views of Plato’s Callicles “in which the ‘weak’ members of a community agree to adopt various conventions such as morality and law in order to prevent the ‘strong’ individuals from overpowering them,” nonetheless argues that Gorgias sees nomos as the exclusive realm of being and change (130). As Cosigny reads Gorgias, nomos shapes identity, though this does not mean Gorgias argues for the status quo. Rather, Gorgias “promotes the institution of the agon, an institution in which people advocate opposed viewpoints and which is therefore an institution of change that encourages people to challenge established beliefs” (131, emphasis in original). Moreover, Cosigny points out that the agon is not in need of any justification from Gorgias with regards to its ethics or political foundation since to do so would admit to foundationalism, a first principle, or a counting to one. Tellingly, Cosigny supports his argument by citing John Rawls’ concept of “reflective equilibrium,” which is seen as “an ongoing hermeneutic project” about what seems the most reasonable belief about the world. In other words, by theorizing the agon as a hermeneutic project of opposed viewpoints, Cosigny emphasizes nomos and leaves little room for physis.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

CeMAP training offered that will help students would comprise 3 parts of exam.

Understanding how motivation works can also help you to learn
how to influence others.

my web site; pobierowo

oakleyses said...

christian louboutin outlet, tiffany and co jewelry, jordan shoes, coach outlet store online, oakley sunglasses, tiffany jewelry, gucci handbags, coach purses, true religion, red bottom shoes, coach outlet, nike free, christian louboutin, coach outlet, prada handbags, kate spade outlet online, oakley vault, nike air max, prada outlet, christian louboutin shoes, longchamp handbags, nike shoes, louis vuitton outlet, ray ban outlet, tory burch outlet, kate spade handbags, chanel handbags, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton handbags, polo ralph lauren outlet, true religion outlet, nike air max, louis vuitton, longchamp outlet online, michael kors outlet online, louis vuitton outlet online, michael kors outlet online, michael kors outlet online, cheap oakley sunglasses, longchamp outlet, louis vuitton outlet, burberry outlet online, michael kors outlet store, michael kors outlet online, polo ralph lauren, burberry outlet online, michael kors outlet

oakleyses said...

air max, burberry pas cher, lacoste pas cher, abercrombie and fitch, true religion jeans, nike roshe run, nike free pas cher, air jordan, north face, ralph lauren, air max pas cher, new balance pas cher, nike trainers, louis vuitton, barbour, lululemon, nike air force, louis vuitton pas cher, oakley pas cher, guess pas cher, ray ban pas cher, ray ban uk, nike free, vans pas cher, nike blazer pas cher, mulberry, ralph lauren pas cher, timberland, hermes pas cher, nike roshe, hollister, sac louis vuitton, hollister, louis vuitton uk, tn pas cher, north face pas cher, chaussure louboutin, longchamp pas cher, michael kors canada, nike air max, true religion outlet, longchamp, converse pas cher, michael kors uk, sac michael kors, scarpe hogan, nike air max, sac vanessa bruno

oakleyses said...

birkin bag, mcm handbags, canada goose, ugg soldes, lululemon outlet, giuseppe zanotti, new balance outlet, chi flat iron, hollister, ugg outlet, mont blanc pens, jimmy choo shoes, herve leger, ugg outlet, soccer jerseys, beats headphones, ugg, nike huarache, nfl jerseys, reebok shoes, abercrombie and fitch, ghd, uggs outlet, insanity workout, canada goose outlet, north face outlet, valentino shoes, longchamp, bottega veneta, p90x workout, wedding dresses, north face jackets, asics shoes, instyler ionic styler, soccer shoes, canada goose outlet, babyliss pro, uggs outlet, roshe run, uggs on sale, marc jacobs outlet, celine handbags, vans outlet, mac cosmetics, rolex watches, ugg boots, ferragamo shoes

oakleyses said...

toms outlet, swarovski jewelry, pandora jewelry, coach outlet, lancel, moncler, juicy couture outlet, pandora uk, moncler, hollister canada, canada goose outlet, hollister clothing, ray ban, oakley, moncler outlet, timberland shoes, baseball bats, canada goose pas cher, vans, gucci, air max, thomas sabo uk, moncler, montre femme, ugg, swarovski uk, louis vuitton canada, wedding dress, ralph lauren, parajumpers outlet, nike air max, uggs canada, hollister, moncler, links of london uk, canada goose uk, converse shoes, canada goose, juicy couture outlet, louboutin, iphone 6 case, canada goose, pandora charms, converse, moncler, supra shoes, moncler, karen millen, replica watches

oakleyses said...

tiffany jewelry, longchamp outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet online, nike air max, replica watches, ugg boots, tiffany and co, replica watches, prada handbags, oakley sunglasses, oakley sunglasses wholesale, louboutin pas cher, christian louboutin, nike air max, christian louboutin outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louis vuitton, polo ralph lauren, longchamp pas cher, polo outlet, christian louboutin uk, nike outlet, air max, longchamp outlet, gucci handbags, oakley sunglasses, kate spade outlet, longchamp outlet, jordan pas cher, ray ban sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, tory burch outlet, prada outlet, oakley sunglasses, sac longchamp pas cher, uggs on sale, michael kors pas cher, louis vuitton outlet, chanel handbags, nike free run, louis vuitton outlet, christian louboutin shoes, burberry pas cher, nike roshe, ugg boots, louis vuitton outlet, ray ban sunglasses

oakleyses said...

hollister uk, michael kors outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet online, converse pas cher, true religion outlet, uggs outlet, lululemon canada, michael kors, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet online, coach outlet store online, nike air max uk, michael kors outlet, vans pas cher, ralph lauren uk, coach purses, michael kors outlet online, nike free uk, polo lacoste, abercrombie and fitch uk, replica handbags, michael kors, true religion jeans, nike air force, sac vanessa bruno, true religion outlet, nike blazer pas cher, ray ban uk, guess pas cher, uggs outlet, hollister pas cher, oakley pas cher, burberry handbags, mulberry uk, timberland pas cher, sac hermes, nike roshe run uk, nike tn, hogan outlet, north face, new balance, ray ban pas cher, nike air max uk, burberry outlet, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet online, north face uk

oakleyses said...

ghd hair, instyler, mcm handbags, beats by dre, giuseppe zanotti outlet, hollister, iphone 6 plus cases, vans outlet, wedding dresses, bottega veneta, ferragamo shoes, ipad cases, new balance shoes, lululemon, jimmy choo outlet, iphone 6s cases, mont blanc pens, nike roshe run, s6 case, insanity workout, nfl jerseys, ralph lauren, valentino shoes, longchamp uk, asics running shoes, north face outlet, celine handbags, hermes belt, hollister clothing, abercrombie and fitch, reebok outlet, baseball bats, soccer jerseys, herve leger, iphone 5s cases, nike huaraches, iphone 6s plus cases, north face outlet, soccer shoes, babyliss, iphone cases, p90x workout, louboutin, oakley, timberland boots, iphone 6 cases, nike air max, mac cosmetics

oakleyses said...

ray ban, hollister, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, toms shoes, louis vuitton, pandora uk, vans, louis vuitton, karen millen uk, canada goose, moncler outlet, moncler, nike air max, moncler outlet, swarovski crystal, gucci, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, ugg uk, canada goose jackets, ugg, canada goose outlet, moncler uk, moncler, canada goose, doudoune moncler, pandora jewelry, canada goose outlet, canada goose uk, lancel, barbour uk, louis vuitton, louis vuitton, barbour, replica watches, marc jacobs, swarovski, thomas sabo, supra shoes, juicy couture outlet, moncler, montre pas cher, pandora charms, links of london, canada goose, pandora jewelry, wedding dresses, converse, converse outlet, louis vuitton, moncler, canada goose outlet, ugg pas cher, coach outlet, hollister

chenlina said...

chenlina20160616
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
michael kors handbags
air force 1
longchamp bags
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
hollister clothing
michael kors outlet
ralph lauren polo
michael kors
toms outlet
louboutin pas cher
nike roshe flyknit
coach outlet
louis vuitton bags
ray ban sunglasses
coach outlet
michael kors outlet
coach factory outlet online
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online
longchamp outlet
air max 90
cheap jordan shoes
oakley sunglasses
adidas running shoes
louis vuitton outlet
nike trainers men
lebron shoes
michael kors handbags
coach outlet store online
fake watches
jordan 4
ray ban outlet
nike air jordan
tiffany jewelry
adidas nmd
ray ban sunglasses outlet
as

Not always theoretical... not even always academic.. but always written..